There on the dock three boys have carved tributes to Emily's beautiful older sister. Both her girlfriends' names have been linked to a boy's there as well. Do you have to be pretty for a boy to like you? It seems so for the new boy, but Emily helps him overcome his problems anyway. What happens later is her reward.
Used availability for C S Adler's Other Girls Are So Pretty
February 2016 : USA, Canada, UK Kindle edition
April 2011 : USA, Canada, UK Kindle edition