book cover of The Christmas Letter Mix-Up
 

The Christmas Letter Mix-Up

(2025)
A Story by

 
 
When Sharon Graber accidentally switches two important letters, her quiet Amish community is thrown into delightful chaos just weeks before Christmas.

Her heartfelt letter confessing her secret feelings for neighbor Eli Lantz somehow finds its way to his mother in Ohio, while Eli receives a letter about an arranged marriage that he believes concerns Sharon. Convinced the woman he's been falling in love with is promised to another man, Eli grows cold and distant.

As Sharon throws herself into organizing the community's Christmas program after the schoolhouse venue is damaged, she can't understand why Eli has suddenly changed toward her. Meanwhile, Eli struggles to hide his pain while secretly searching for Sharon's lost family heirloom—her beloved grandmother's silver thimble.

When Eli's mother arrives unexpectedly from Ohio, armed with Sharon's accidentally misdirected love letter, the truth about the mix-up finally comes to light. But can two confused hearts find their way back to each other in time for Christmas?
And will Sharon's mortifying mistake turn out to be the blessing that brings them together?

Set against the backdrop of Amish Christmas traditions and community spirit, A Christmas Letter Mix-Up is a heartwarming tale of how God works through our mistakes to accomplish His perfect will—and how sometimes the most embarrassing errors lead to the most beautiful beginnings.


Genre: Inspirational

Used availability for Hannah Miller's The Christmas Letter Mix-Up


About Fantastic Fiction       Information for Authors